How Did Sam Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research Lose So Much Money? (2024)

By Jeff Kauflin, Emily Mason and Nina Bambysheva

A week after the dramatic collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried’s tangled web of crypto companies, countless unanswered questions remain. One of the biggest: How did his trading firm, Alameda Research, apparently lose billions of dollars? Those losses appear to have prompted someone in Bankman-Fried’s operation to improperly transfer customer funds from trading platform FTX to Alameda, a decision that left FTX vulnerable to a withdrawal run that precipitated the sudden bankruptcy.

Many details remain unknown, but a blurry picture is forming of the possible causes behind Alameda’s steep losses. We spoke with a half-dozen crypto traders and investors familiar with Alameda to understand the leading theories. A spokesperson for Sam Bankman-Fried and Alameda’s former co-CEOs Caroline Ellison and Sam Trabucco didn’t respond to Forbes’ requests for comment. We sent Bankman-Fried questions on messaging app Signal, but he hasn’t yet answered them.

Moving From Arbitrage to High-Risk Bets

The first theory is that the young traders at Alameda, which was once one of the largest crypto trading firms in the world, weren’t as sophisticated as their reputation suggested. Bankman-Fried was regarded as an excellent trader when he started Alameda in 2018, and he focused on arbitraging price differences in cryptocurrencies in different markets. But the next year, he shifted his primary focus to launching his trading platform FTX. He brought with him to FTX his Alameda colleagues Gary Wang and Nishad Singh, who had been some of the most talented people at the trading firm, according to Doug Colkitt, a veteran high frequency stock trader turned crypto trader.

After bitcoin started to rise sharply in the fall of 2020, Alameda moved away from its initial focus on making high-speed, market-neutral bets that didn’t depend on predicting if cryptocurrencies would rise or fall. Some traders believe Alameda changed its strategy because it lost its competitive edge as more experienced firms like Jump ramped up their crypto trading business.

In March 2021, then 26-year-old Caroline Ellison, one of Alameda’s co-CEOs, seemed to acknowledge this pivot when she tweeted, “Also relatable is the point where he realizes he's been wasting time trying to trade back and forth for a few points of edge and the way to really make money is figure out when the market is going to go up and get balls long before that.” Going long means betting that prices will rise.

A month later, Sam Trabucco, Alameda’s other co-CEO, tweeted, “we got ... uh, really long in winter 2020.” As a rationale for why, he added, “it’s where the money is.” Both Ellison and Trabucco had just a couple of years of trading experience in conventional markets before joining Bankman-Fried to deal in crypto. That’s a shallow pool of knowledge and experience to draw on.

According to several traders, many of Alameda’s long bets probably suffered big losses beginning in May 2022, after the dramatic collapse of the stable coin terraUSD and its sister cryptocurrency luna sharpened the decline in the crypto market. “What makes you a hero in bull markets kills you in bear markets,” says Marina Gurevich, chief operating officer of London-based Wintermute, one of the most active crypto trading firms in the world. Indeed, Bankman-Fried acknowledged in a Twitter conversation with a Vox reporter that it was around the time of luna’s crash when a lot of risky leverage built up in his business.

Layering Leverage on Top of Big Bets

On top of making big bets, Alameda was likely taking on too much leverage–that is, debt that can amplify wins and losses. One way the firm’s executives apparently did that was by using largely illiquid cryptocurrencies–including FTX’s own token, FTT, and a related one, serum–as collateral to take out loans.

For example, Bankman-Fried helped incubate the creation of serum, which was released in 2020. Serum has a low circulating supply of coins–initially, only 10% of it was freely tradeable, while the other 90% was locked up for years. But technically, he could extrapolate and assume that, if the circulating supply of serum was worth $1 billion, then the market value of all the coins in existence was $10 billion. Then he could get loans based on that higher valuation. Bankman-Fried ran this playbook with other digital assets too, which became known as “Sam coins” to industry insiders, crypto investor Jason Choi has written.

Choi concluded recently in a tweet, “This is likely how Alameda/FTX incurred the multi-billion-dollar hole: Alameda pledging illiquid collateral to borrow money to finance bets, which got margin called as markets went down this year.”

Investing Borrowed Money in Other Crypto Players

Another capital drain was venture investments. According to PitchBook, Alameda made more than 150 investments across the crypto industry, including in bitcoin miner Genesis Digital Mining and now-bankrupt crypto broker Voyager Digital. Alameda apparently took out loans to fund those bets. As the crypto market crashed, lenders reportedly attempted to recall those funds that were tied up in these illiquid investments. FTX’s and Alameda’s executives then took the questionable step of trying to pay back some of those Alameda loans using FTX customer funds, the Wall Street Journal has reported.

Borrowing for Other Big Spending

The finances of Bankman-Fried’s cluster of companies are so complex and entangled that huge chunks of it remain a mystery–even to the lawyers, financial investigators and bankruptcy veterans who have taken charge. But according to bankruptcy court filings, FTX executives also took out billions of dollars in loans from Alameda to fund everything from political contributions to Bankman-Fried’s purchase for $650 million of a 7.6% stake in Robinhood. It’s unclear how these loans may have also added to Alameda’s losses on top of everything else. Alameda itself has outstanding liabilities of $5.1 billion according to a filing Thursday in the Chapter 11 bankruptcy case in Delaware.

Shoddy Record-Keeping and Accounting Controls

A final–and perhaps substantial–contributor to Alameda’s losses: Bankman-Fried’s companies had terrible record-keeping and accounting systems. FTX customer deposits were not tracked, according to a bankruptcy filing, leaving it unclear in the bankruptcy proceedings what’s owed to customers. An example of this confusion: the leaked FTX balance sheet shows $8.8 billion in liabilities, while the Thursday filing in the Delaware bankruptcy case shows only $6.4 billion. It’s not clear what accounts for the discrepancy, but regardless, the numbers are still in flux. “This balance sheet was produced while the Debtors were controlled by Mr. Bankman-Fried, I do not have confidence in it,” workout veteran John J. Ray III, the new CEO of FTX overseeing the bankruptcy wrote in the filing. Bankman-Fried has tried to chalk up nearly the entire problem to “messy accounting + margin.”

Bankman-Fried’s careless accounting habits appear to date back to the earliest days of Alameda. When crypto venture capitalist Alex Pack was considering investing in Alameda in early 2019 and conducting due diligence, he saw they had lost $10 million in a single month–a hefty sum for such a small firm. When Pack asked about it, Bankman-Fried said it was due to “trade errors,’’ Pack recalls.

Pack says he kept probing, but he could never figure out what happened. “At one point, they just said, ‘Sorry, we didn't have great record keeping back then. We can’t answer all these questions.’” Pack passed on the deal. He thought they seemed like smart traders but walked away due to what he saw as “significant recklessness around risk taking and extremely poor infrastructure and accounting.”

Today, Pack says tracking positions in crypto can be particularly hard because you have to build your own trading systems, and the task gets “exponentially more difficult” as your book of business grows. And if Alameda started with bad accounting systems, Pack says it’s “not inconceivable” that they could have ended up with much more debt than they realized, as Bankman-Fried has claimed.

How Did Sam Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research Lose So Much Money? (2024)


How Did Sam Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research Lose So Much Money? ›

Shoddy Record-Keeping and Accounting Controls

How did Alameda Research lose so much money? ›

The leading theories on why Alameda lost so much range from big bets gone wrong to having godawful accounting records. Those theories might explain why Alameda lost money in 2022 when crypto was crashing, but its losses through 2021 remain a big mystery.

Why did Alameda Research borrow money from FTX? ›

Alameda was a customer on FTX and has two trading accounts with the exchange. As a customer, Alameda could borrow money from FTX, Bankman-Fried said. The borrowed money came from margin traders, collateral or crypto assets earning interest on the exchange, he said.

What happened at Alameda Research Milky Eggs? ›

When loans were recalled in early 2022, an emergency decision was made to use FTX users' deposits to repay creditors. This repayment spurred on increasingly erratic behavior and unprofitable gambling, eventually resulting in total insolvency.

How did FTX move money to Alameda? ›

It's often dollars, or something else of value — like real estate. In this case, a source said Alameda was borrowing from FTX, and using the exchange's in-house cryptocurrency, FTT token, to back those loans. The price of the FTT token nosedived 75% in a day, making the collateral insufficient to cover the trade.

What went wrong with Alameda Research? ›

A final–and perhaps substantial–contributor to Alameda's losses: Bankman-Fried's companies had terrible record-keeping and accounting systems. FTX customer deposits were not tracked, according to a bankruptcy filing, leaving it unclear in the bankruptcy proceedings what's owed to customers.

How much money did Alameda Research make? ›

As Lewis relates, Bankman-Fried grew Alameda Research from a small group of effective altruists to a firm generating upwards of a billion dollars in annual profit by 2020.

What happened between FTX and Alameda? ›

A surge of customer withdrawals due to concerns over this questionable financial valuation practice and unusually close relationship with Alameda pushed FTX and Alameda into bankruptcy and shook the volatile crypto market.

Who leaked Alameda balance sheet? ›

Evidence presented as part of Sam Bankman-Fried's trial shows that he held Binance responsible for leaking a balance sheet for Alameda Research to CoinDesk, the media outlet — a key episode in the collapse of FTX and his crypto empire.

What caused FTX to fall? ›

When FTX could not pay the $8 billion gap, the company filed for bankruptcy. FTX crashed due to mismanagement of funds, lack of liquidity and the large volume of withdrawals.

What was Alameda doing? ›

As a quantitative trading firm specializing in cryptocurrencies, Alameda's strategies included arbitrage, market making, yield farming, and trading volatility.

Is FTX's original sin a warning to all of crypto? ›

FTX's Original Sin Is a Warning to All of Crypto; Evidence from the criminal trial of Sam Bankman-Fried suggests fraud was built into FTX from the very beginning.

How did Alameda loose money? ›

In a series of X threads, former Alameda engineer Aditya Baradwaj has been shedding light on the company's operations, including some eye-popping and genuinely incompetent fumbles: $100 million lost because a trader clicked a phishing link; $40 million sent into the void on a fat-fingered transaction; $50 million lost ...

Who loaned money to Alameda Research? ›

Alameda Research borrowed money from FTX to fund its trading activities. Alameda Research is a quantitative trading firm founded by Sam Bankman-Fried, the former CEO of FTX. The firm borrowed billions of dollars from FTX, using its own cryptocurrency, FTT, as collateral.

Did FTX people get their money back? ›

FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried, left, arrives at a federal courthouse in Manhattan on Feb. 16, 2023. Nearly all customers of FTX will get their money back, plus interest, after the cryptocurrency exchange imploded 17 months ago.

How did FTX lose all its money? ›

FTX was a leading cryptocurrency exchange that went bankrupt in November 2022 amid allegations that its owners had embezzled and misused customer funds. Sam Bankman-Fried, the CEO of the exchange, was sentenced to 25 years in prison and ordered to repay $11 billion.

What happened to Alameda Research CEO? ›

Ellison was terminated from her position after FTX and Alameda filed for bankruptcy. In December 2022, Ellison pleaded guilty to two counts of wire fraud, two counts of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit securities fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

What is Alameda's failure to hedge? ›

In a document titled “Alameda's Failure to Hedge,” Sam Bankman-Fried blames Caroline Ellison for the collapse of both Alameda & FTX, stating that “if Alameda had hedged properly then, neither it, nor FTX, would have blown out, […] but instead Caroline didn't hedge until the summer of 2022.” I received this document in ...

Did FTX customers get their money back? ›

Almost all customers of collapsed cryptocurrency exchange FTX will get their money back — and more, according to a court filing. FTX estimates that it owes creditors around $11.2 billion. FTX said that it has between $14.5 billion and $16.3 billion to distribute to creditors.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6307

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Birthday: 1996-05-10

Address: Apt. 425 4346 Santiago Islands, Shariside, AK 38830-1874

Phone: +96313309894162

Job: Legacy Sales Designer

Hobby: Baseball, Wood carving, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Lacemaking, Parkour, Drawing

Introduction: My name is Dean Jakubowski Ret, I am a enthusiastic, friendly, homely, handsome, zealous, brainy, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.